Toilet flappers are very simple to replace and are easy on the pocket as well.
If your toilet is leaking or the flush isn’t working as it is supposed to, it is time to replace the toilet flapper.
However, many brands in the market try to take their spot, so to make selection easier, you can choose the right toilet flapper here.
The best toilet flappers are the ones that offer efficient water use, flush adjustment, and a powerful seal.
I have written this complete guide, including reviews, buyers guide, and frequently asked questions to help you purchase the best toilet flapper.
Top 8 Toilet Flapper Reviews
Let’s go through the best toilet flappers currently out in the market. Each toilet flapper is well researched for the review, along with its pros and cons.
1. American Standard Universal Flapper
Talking about toilet fixtures and American standard doesn’t offer their product? That not likely.
The American standard universal flapper is great for all 2-inch valves. You can manually adjust the closing speed with its chain and rounded float.
It is integrated with small clips in the user’s inner side to adjust the height without a problem.
This is a great option as you get a dual flushing mechanism just by adjusting the height. If you want a short flush, place the floater higher near to the lever’s arm.
However, if you want a bigger flush, place the floater near to the valve. Let’s talk about the flapper; it is made of a durable frame, black in color, and a bendable rubber ball.
If you are looking for a long-lasting toilet flapper, you should get the American standard universal flapper.
- Adjustable float
- Powerful seal
- Tedious installation
2. Hibbent 2 Pack Toilet Replacement
The Hibbent toilet flapper is an affordable option if you are looking forward to replacing your old leaky toilet flapper.
This toilet flapper’s body is made of long-lasting blue colored rubber that is treated perfectly for hard water and well water.
It includes a stainless steel chain and a clip hook that offer effortless installation in just minutes. The best part is that it comes in a pack of two for a very reasonable price.
- Silicone seal
- Little flimsy
3. Kohler Blue Part Flapper
The Kohler toilet flapper comes in a variety of packages depending on how many you require.
If you want to save a lot of water regularly, the Kohler toilet flapper is the best choice. It is built out of industry-grade Styrofoam that ensures sturdiness and high-efficiency.
One of the best features of the Kohler toilet flapper is that you can get the right flapper by entering your toilet’s model number if you own a Kohler toilet.
How convenient right? Only Kohler can deliver such ease. It is, hands down, one of the best toilet flappers in the market.
- Industry-grade materials
- Easy to identify model
- Technical installation
4. TOTO THU500S
TOTO is well known to manufacture great quality toilet fixtures, and it has also mastered producing toilet flappers.
The TOTO toilet flapper is universal and will fit all the toilets. It is made out of the highest quality imported rubber and is also affordable at the same time.
It is designed to have a polypropylene body with a rubber seal.
It comes with a chain for hassle-free installation for you to save time and maintain your bathroom with ease.
- Strong rubber seal
- Easy to install
- Not universal
5. Fluidmaster 5403
The fluid master toilet flapper can handle 3-inch valves and toilets that deliver 1.28 to 3.5 gallons per flush.
The fluid master’s seal is made out of durable silicone, which keeps it intact, and the high-quality frame adds to its long-life.
This toilet flapper is designed with Microban technology that fights germs and bacteria to keep you safe and healthy.
You can adjust the flush levels by simply twisting the dial anti-clockwise for a long flush or clockwise for a water-saving flush.
You have a whopping nine settings to choose from with the great fluid master 5403.
- Microban technology
- Durable frame
- Not a universal fit
6. Korky 100BP
Korky offers a great number of toilet flapper models, and the 100BP is one of them.
The 100BP is a universal toilet flapper that fits most 2 inch valves and is integrated with a flexible chlorazone rubber seal to prevent leakages or clogs.
If you have an old toilet and are looking to conserve more water, the Korky 100BP allows you to adjust flush levels for more sustainable living.
This toilet flapper is built to withhold chlorine, hard water, and bacteria. It comes with a stainless-steel chain and should be the perfect choice for a great toilet flapper.
- Strong rubber seal
- Durable frame
- Adjustable flush
- Attachment bracket weak
7. Fluidmaster 502P21
Another Fluid master model offers similar features with a few tweaks here and there. It is a universal flapper that can fit into all 3-inch flush valves.
The installation is very easy, and the sturdy injection-molded frame features a silicone seal and a kink-free chain.
You can adjust the flush levels with this model to make your toilet a water-saving one.
If you are looking for a highly durable toilet flapper, the fluid master 502P21 should be your choice.
- Intact seal
- Not long-lasting
8. Korky TOTO 2022BP
The Korky TOTO is specially designed to fit all the TOTO model toilets. This toilet flapper is most suited for 3-inch valves but does not offer adjustments to the flushing.
It does offer great quality and immense ease of setting up. There are no tools required to install the flapper and the stainless-steel chain.
The flexible rubber offers a powerful seal, and the entire frame is corrosion-resistant. Therefore, if you have a TOTO toilet, this flapper is for you.
- Easy to set up
- Powerful seal
- Resistant to hard water
- Not durable enough
Buyer’s Guide – How to Choose the Best Toilet Flapper
Buying the best toilet flapper can be a tough task and should be done with great research beforehand.
To ensure that you get the right toilet flapper, I have a list of factors that should consider before buying them.
This is the most significant factor to keep in mind, your investment will go to waste.
You have to know your flush valve size before selecting the best toilet flapper.
If you get the size that does not match with your valve, you may face water leakage.
You should check the material of the flapper’s body and the seal as well. A long-lasting, sturdy toilet flapper will be corrosion and rust-resistant.
Silicone, rubber, plastic, Styrofoam, and polypropylene are all the popular materials used in making a toilet flapper with a strong seal.
A toilet flapper that offers flushing adjustability is a great choice for all those looking to save water.
With an adjustable toilet flapper, you can control how long or short your flush will be, and thus, such an efficient flushing system will save you a lot of costs.
Frequently Asked Questions
Below is a list of questions that are frequently asked by customers. I have researched the best possible answers to save you time.
When should I replace my toilet flapper?
Ans. You should replace your toilet flapper if your toilet is leaking or your flush isn’t working efficiently. In both cases, consider replacing your old toilet flapper with a new one.
How does a toilet flapper help me save water?
Ans. A toilet flapper will help you save a lot of water if it allows the floater, cap, or ruler to be adjusted.
Once you adjust the gap between the valve and the floater according to your preference, you will keep the flush long or short.
What is the right toilet flapper size?
Ans. Your toilet will either have a 2-inch, 3-inch, or, in some cases, 4-inch flush valve; your toilet flapper should fit right according to the measurements of the valve.
For a tight, secure seal and installation, you should know the measurements.
What does it mean by universal fit?
Ans. A universal fit toilet flapper means it will fit most of the different toilet brands, but you still have to get the one that fits your toilet’s valve measurement.
How long do toilet flappers last?
Ans. The durability depends on the quality of the toilet flapper. Typically, toilet flappers last for four to five years.
Is installing a toilet flapper technical?
Ans. Installing a toilet flapper is a very easy task that can be performed in a matter of minutes.
Buying the best toilet flapper can help you contribute and bring change, even if there is a minor change in saving water, but it will be worthy in the long run.
Toilet flappers will not only save water but also keep you safe from leakages.
I hope the shortlisted toilets and the buyers’ guide have helped you choose the best toilet flapper.
If there is anything you want me to know or discuss further, please mention it in the comments section below.